CO129-073 - Lieut. Governor Caine & Sir Bowring - 1859 [1-5] — Page 5

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

The suit sprang out of the libel case already reported to the Secretary of State in Despatchs No 5 of 28th April, 1858.

I enclose the Acting Attorney General's report, which, from it will be seen that, by direction of the Chief Justice the Jury found for the Defendant, a verdict. And Mr. Anstey the Plaintiff's Counsel, gave notices of appeals to the Privy Council.

I have very much doubt if the appeal will be prosecuted, and certainly have no fear that it will be sustained.

As regards Mr. Pitman's suggestions made in the conclusion of Mr. Croon's report, I have to state that I am unaware what fine or other punishment can be imposed upon those Jurymen who being summoned were absent, and consequently can give no opinions on this point, save that it would seem that additional strictness in place of modification were necessary, if any alteration be necessary, in the Jury system of the Colony.

With regard to the other point, it shall have attention.

Edit History

2026-05-18 10:10:45 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
The suit sprang out of the libel case already reported to the Secretary of State in Despatchs No 5 of 28th April, 1858.I enclose the Acting Attorney General's report, which, from it will be seen that, by direction of the Chief Justice the Jury found for the Defendant, a verdict. And Mr. Anstey the Plaintiff's Counsel, gave notices of appeals to the Privy Council.I have very much doubt if the appeal will be prosecuted, and certainly have no fear that it will be sustained.As regards Mr. Pitman's suggestions made in the conclusion of Mr. Croon's report, I have to state that I am unaware what fine or other punishment can be imposed upon those Jurymen who being summoned were absent, and consequently can give no opinions on this point, save that it would seem that additional strictness in place of modification were necessary, if any alteration be necessary, in the Jury system of the Colony.With regard to the other point, it shall have attention.
Baseline (Original)
The suit sprang out of the libel, case alreadypeported to the Sunstary of State inSecretary Despatchs No S Jof 28th April, 1858.of theWonclose the Acting Horney General's report, hial, fromwhich it will be seen that, by direction of the Chief Justice the Jury forend 1 for thes Befendant, a perdict.and otM. Anstey the Paintyiffe Counsel, gave notices of appeals to the Privy Council.a1vary mechs doubt, if the appeal will be prosecuted, and certainly have no fear that it will be sustained.3•As regards Priters cuggestions made in the conclusion of Mr. Croon's report, I have to state; that Tam unaware what fine was wasنده other peenishment cone imposed upon those Jurijmen who bring summoned were absent, and consequently cans give no opinions on this point, saves that it would seem rej fadditional strictness in place of modification were necessary, if a my alteration be necessary, in the Juryplanne of the Colony.With regard to the other point, it challshaves attention,
2026-05-18 10:10:45 · Baseline
View content

The suit sprang out

of

the libel, case alreadypeported to the Sunstary of State in

Secretary

Despatchs No S Jof 28th April,

1858.

of the

Wonclose the Acting Horney General's report, hial, from which it will be seen that, by direction of the Chief Justice the Jury forend 1 for thes Befendant,

a perdict.

and ot

M. Anstey the Painty

iffe

Counsel, gave notices of appeals

to the Privy Council.

a1

vary mechs doubt,

if

the appeal will be prosecuted,

and certainly

have no fear

that it will be sustained.

3

•As regards Priters cuggestions made in the conclusion of Mr. Croon's report, I have to state; that Tam unaware what fine

was was

نده

other peenishment cone imposed

upon those Jurijmen who bring

summoned were absent, and consequently cans give

no

opinions on this point, saves that it would seem rej fadditional strictness in place of modification were necessary, if a my alteration be necessary, in the Juryplanne of the Colony.

With regard to the other point, it challshaves attention,

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.